The objective of this article is to emphasize redemocratization as a horizon for historiography and the teaching of history in contemporary times based on two readings of Capistrano de Abreu. Without intending to exhaust the critical wealth on the supposed first modern historian of Brazilian historiography, we focus our attention on “Ronda noturna”, by Ricardo Benzaquen, and “Mas não somente assim!”, by Ilmar Mattos. If “Ronda noturna” announces the risk of modern historiography canceling out chance in history through the construction of a univocal meaning, dialoguing with this same diagnosis, “Mas não somente assim!” pluralizes the understanding of what authorship is by recognizing reading, or reception, as a path to its production.