This article analyzes the teaching of History of Education in initial teacher education in three higher education institutions in General Pico (La Pampa, Argentina), with the aim of identifying what structural tensions shape this practice and how they condition the pedagogical possibilities for teachers and students. Drawing on a qualitative interpretive approach that combines thematic analysis with biographical-narrative inquiry, and grounded in a collective exchange device and the analysis of curricula and course programs, five constitutive tensions are identified: the curricular position of the subject, theoretical density and content selection, teaching approaches, assessment strategies, and difficulties in articulating with other training areas. The article proposes reading these tensions not only as structural features of the field, but as experiences constructed and reformulated across concrete teaching and learning trajectories.